Every one is a complete Diagnostic — all eight moats scored 0–3, the tier assigned off the count of real moats rather than the total, and the gap between what the company markets and what actually defends it named outright.
Gokul Rajaram's eight categories of competitive advantage, first laid out in his 20VC interview with Harry Stebbings. Each one is scored on its own, because no single moat is defensible on its own — a company stacks or it doesn't. Every moat also has a way it stops working, which is what the score is really testing for.
Proprietary data that improves the product and can't be bought.
A competitor buys the same source, or the model layer commoditizes the insight.
Embedded in how work gets done, so leaving means re-learning.
A new interface layer sits on top and does the workflow for the user.
Licences, certifications, and compliance positions competitors must earn.
The rules change, or the barrier is lowered and everyone qualifies.
Channels and relationships that reach buyers others can't.
The channel changes its terms, or the partner builds the thing itself.
Third parties who've built on you and would bear the cost of your loss.
The platform absorbs your function, and the builders move up a layer.
Value that rises with participation rather than with spend.
Multi-homing. Users join both, and exclusivity quietly disappears.
Infrastructure and assets that take capital and time to replicate.
Capital arrives and someone builds it newer, cheaper, or closer.
Cost position that improves with volume faster than a challenger's.
A challenger with different economics doesn't need your volume to compete.
Every moat has a way it stops working. That's the argument for scoring all eight rather than defending the one you're proudest of — the failure modes are independent, so depth in a single moat is one bad quarter away from being nothing. Before any of the eight counts toward the tier, it's checked against Hamilton Helmer's 7 Powers, so what scores here is a real barrier to competition, not a strength that just sounds like one.
Gokul named the eight categories. He didn't publish failure modes for each one or a way to score them. Those — the "fails when" for every moat, the 0–3 scoring, and the tier assigned off the count of moats that clear a 2 — are the instrument I've built: the 8 Moats Diagnostic and Scorecard, on top of his framework. More on how it works →
The set runs the full ladder on purpose — a 2/24 sitting next to an 18/24 tells you more about the instrument than fifteen respectable scores would. Choose one and I'll send you the link to the full scorecard.
The same instrument runs on your company — all eight moats, the tier, and the one gap between your story and your structure. Free, and it comes back the next business day. Get your free diagnostic →